Saturday, July 9, 2016
Is it possible that the most important trade goods in the Polynesian Pacific were blocks of rock?
Increasing evidence indicates that stone tools and tool blanks were carried during numerous heroic long-distance canoe voyages, and that those voyages continued at least into the period when Europeans appeared in the Pacific.
Perhaps the more important message of the traveling stones is that the Eastern Polynesian island communities stayed connected for centuries after initial colonization.
“In East Polynesia, long-distance interaction between island societies was a fundamental colonization strategy linking parent with multiple daughter communities to support the establishment of socially and economically viable groups,” says a new report in PNAS, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
The authors of “Cook Island artifact geochemistry demonstrates spatial and temporal extent of pre-European interarchipelago voyaging in East Polynesia” include an international set of geological and anthropolical superstars: Marshall Weisler, Robert Bolhar, Jinlong Ma, Emma St Pierre, Peter Sheppard, Richard K. Walter, Yuexing Feng, Jian-xin Zhao, and Patrick V. Kirch.
They report on the provenance of stone adzes and associated materials found in a venerable rock shelter on the Cook Islands island of Mangaia. The shelter is called Tangatatau, and it was used for hundreds of years. The stone adzes were found in layers of sediment that could be dated.
Here is a report on the research from the Australian network, ABC.
Researchers have known for some time that adzes did a lot of traveling. We reported in 2007 on an adze found in the Tuamotu chain, which came from an adze quarry on Kaho`olawe, in Hawai`i.
So it was, perhaps, not surprising that the Mangaia rock shelter had adzes from around the eastern Pacific. Some sources were just a few hundred miles away, in the Cooks and the Austral Islands, but there was also material that could be linked to quarries in Samoa and the Marquesas—more than 1,000 miles away. Those were significant distances, and there were indications of repeat voyages.
The Samoan connection is notable because Samoa is considered part of West Polynesia. It is considered the jumping-off point for inhabitation of the Eastern Pacific Islands (Tahiti, Marquesas, Hawaii, Cooks, Australs. Rapa Nui, Pitcairn, etc.) And until now, it was assumed that contact between West and East Polynesia died out early, allowing the Eastern Polynesian culture to develop on its own.
“This evidence for continued voyaging contact between the Cook Islands and Samoa is … of considerable import because it has often been tacitly assumed that there was little or no contact between the island groups of East Polynesia and the West Polynesian homeland region, after the initial settlement of East Polynesia,” the authors write.
Another issue is why is all the stone tool voyaging only brought tools into Mangaia, and not the other way. Why were the Marquesas, Samoa and the Australs entirely exporters of stone, and Mangaia entirely an import culture? Or will further archaeology show it was a two-way transport?
Two big questions: Why did the voyaging continue for so long? And why did it end?
Here’s how Weisler and his team answer the first question.
“Postcolonization voyaging and interaction supported socially mediated imperatives such as the acquisition of high status goods, the fostering and maintenance of strategic alliances, and establishing individual and group prowess or ‘mana.’”
They assume some ceremonial component, since Mangaia has its own adz quarries, unlike the Tuamotu archipelago, where most islands are atolls and hard basalt rock is difficult to acquire. Mangaia didn't need the stone, but still, voyagers brought the stone.
The authors don’t have a ready answer for the second question—why the voyaging stopped. There is indication that the most distant island groups dropped out of the trade web earliest. Hawai`i is by far the most distant group from the others, and its presence in the artifacts of the South Pacific thus far has only been established by the one adze found on the Tuamotu atoll of Napuka, 2,500 miles from Kaho`olawe.
The researchers of the Mangaia stone tools report that materials continued to flow in a one-way pattern into Mangaia for as long as 300 years.
“A large corpus of radiocarbon age determinations and associated imported adze material from Tangatatau documents the time span of interarchipelago voyaging from the early AD 1300s to at least the 1600s,” they wrote.
The paper does not address it, but there was something else happening in the Eastern Pacific about the time of the end of voyaging.
European ships were appearing.
The Portuguese explorer Magellan came through the Pacific from east to west in 1520, although he missed Polynesia and made his first landfall on Guam.
The Marquesas were visited perhaps as early as 1526 by the Spanish, and were given their European name by Spanish explorer Alvaro de Mendana in 1595. De Mendana also spotted Pukapuka in what would be the Cook Islands. His navigator de Quiros was in the Tuamotu in 1606, and walked on the Cooks’ Rakahanga shortly afterward.
The Dutch were in the region in 1616 (Schouten and Le Maire), 1643 (Tasman) and again in 1722 (Roggeveen).
The British didn’t show up until the late 1700s, but ended up spending more time in Eastern Polynesia than any of the others. Capt. James Cook spotted Mangaia in 1777, the year before he sailed into Hawai`i.
But it was the Polynesian voyaging era that was the most historic. The Europeans came through in discovery vessels. But the Polynesians migrated. They brought their whole culture and created new island communities.
“Oceania, the last region settled on Earth, witnessed the greatest maritime migration in human history,” wrote authors of the Mangaia stone artifact study.
© Jan TenBruggencate 2016